Book direct with us for the best prices

The Best Restaurants in Cartagena: Where We Actually Send Our Guests

Quick answer

For the best restaurants in Cartagena, Colombia, we send guests to three places in the city and keep one out here on the island. Celele in Getsemaní for Caribbean cooking built on ingredient research, Carmen inside the walled city for contemporary Colombian, Buena Vida Marisquería in Getsemaní for seafood, and our own kitchen on Tierra Bomba, where Chef Pedro Mosqueda cooks farm-to-table with what the islands grow and catch. Book all of them ahead. Our boat leaves the Muelle de la Bodeguita at 10am, 11:30am and 5pm, so an island lunch and a city dinner fit into one day.

People sitting at tables in our outdoor restaurant at dusk
Dinner service at our place on Tierra Bomba, 25 minutes by boat from Cartagena.

We get asked where to eat in Cartagena more than almost anything else, usually by someone already holding a list of forty restaurants they found online. So here is a short one instead.

We run a kitchen 25 minutes offshore, which means we eat in the city on our days off and we hear back from guests the morning after. These are the four places we're comfortable putting our name to: three in town, one of them ours out here on Tierra Bomba. Four, not forty. If a place isn't on this list it isn't a judgement on it, it just means we can't vouch for it this week.

Two practical things first. Reserve, for all of them. Cartagena's good tables fill up from December through February and over Colombian holiday weekends, and turning up at 8pm on a Saturday hoping for a table is optimistic. And check with the restaurant the day before rather than trusting a screenshot, because hours and menus in this city move around, ours included. We checked these names against current listings in October 2026.

One more thing if you're thinking about coming to us. Our boat leaves the Muelle de la Bodeguita at 10am, 11:30am and 5pm, and heads back from our dock at 4pm and 5:30pm. Lunch out here and dinner inside the walls is a normal day, not an ambitious one.

Book your stay at Blue Apple Beach